Shelldon was the name given to our egg in the "An Eggs-cellent Way to Plan" assignment. Although it appears that there isn't consensus as to the actual spelling of the egg. I side with those that want to make the pun obvious.
In any case, although the project we would undertake would be fun, it was necessary to follow a certain protocol in order to be able to "land" the egg without any harm. In reviewing the 5 Stages of planning, the process appears to be somewhat organic. Although we had been introduced to the planning process, we didn't feel constricted or aware of a set regimen. The presence of the deadline element definitely streamlined the process and before we knew it we were active participants in the planning process.
The 1st Step: Define your goals and objectives. This step was more implicit in the assignment. We all had access to the rules and the final product required of us. The group members which did not grasp all the requirements were made aware during the first 25 minutes of the planning process. It was evident that the most limiting restriction was the low level of materials to build the egg-preserving machine.
The 2nd Step: I think there were two camps in our group. Those which understood the limitations of the materials, and those which underestimated the limited use of materials. I was in the second camp. I didn't realize that 2 feet of tape was extremely restrictive in producing a complex machine. Yet, those group members who visualized the restrictive lenght and low number of straws made the others well aware that some of our ideas would simply not work. Our group had a considerable debate as to how big a straw was, and whether we could make a modified parachute out of it. One of my team members immediately got up, brought us a straw and by seeing the actual size scrapped some of the most resource-heavy proposals. Communication was also difficult. Some people had great ideas and their conviction of how it would work was contagious, but needed visual clarity. Committing the idea to paper proved discouraging. Other people listened carefully, visualized the suggestions and quickly sketched the idea, therefore allowing every team member to gasp audibly in approval and concord.
The 3rd Step: The first 25 minutes went by pretty smoothly; ideas were thrown around bouncing off one team member to another one. A practical idea was appropriated by another team member therefore improving the chance of success. What I admired about our group was that when a certain idea was mentioned (a modified parachute device) it wasn't quickly dismissed but rather we all went over the specifications, thought about its negative aspects and we all realized that we lacked the resources to execute such a device.
The 4th Step: One team member came up with a practical solution and another member promoted it vigorously. This idea would then become the one which we would implement in the 10 minutes required in producing it. I was skeptical of the idea but realized that given the circumstance this idea would probably work. I therefore yielded to these two team members and they were the ones which delegated the roles. (cut here, tape this, etc.)
The 5th Step: This step would prove to be the most difficult one, considering we were allowed only 10 minutes and had to run around the room chasing the one scissor available. I failed in retrieving the scissor to make the last needed splicing of the straw but someone my team managed to take the vision and make it a reality. Upon viewing the other devices, many of our team members were quit confident that our plan would work...and it did, with the exception of a small crack crawling on the side of the shell. Such a small crack that it took the professor 2 minutes to disqualify our invention.
Friday, March 6, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think having a good plan process really requires more brains to work together. Very similar to my group, we each have some knowledge about something. Due to that fact, we were able to point out any little problems that can cause the egg to break. We were able to combine our knowledge together to make a good protector for our group.
ReplyDeleteIt seems your group has the same issue as mine, which was time management. At the end we were very rushed but somehow we pulled off the five points. We both needed someone just watching the clock during the whole process
ReplyDeletei believe the time that was assigned to the egg dropping activity either for the planning process or the execution of the plan,was reasonably sufficient given the limited resources and the size of the assignment. the main issue, in my point of view, was getting people to agree about one practical, final and winning egg design.
ReplyDeleteTime played a very important role in this project. We were also chasing the scissors and the worst part was that we needed to make several cuts, so having a single pair of scissors made it difficult because the rest of us had to stand there staring at each other waiting for our turn. I still think it was a fun project.
ReplyDelete